adamu wrote: ↑Mon Feb 05, 2024 12:51 pm
cocacola wrote: ↑Mon Feb 05, 2024 6:34 am
The intrinsic value in bitcoin is not in the tangible use that it possesses, but in how it cannot be controlled by any single entity.
This is true for all cryptocurrencies, not just Bitcoin. Even Bitcoin, anyone can make a clone of it at a whim (and have, see Bitcoin Cash, Bitcoin Gold).
Anyway, nothing here specific to Japan and I'm just going to rehash the same old arguments so I'll bow out now.
I know that you are finished with this topic, but for the clarity of others reading: decentralization (no control by a single entity) and forking a codebase are two different things. My point with bitcoin is that there is no, one person or corporation that controls bitcoin, thus its decentralization. Any changes proposed to the bitcoin code must be voted upon by members of the bitcoin core developer team. The original creator of bitcoin, "Satoshi Nakamoto" (most likely a pseudonym), sent his/her/their final communication in 2011 and hasn't been heard from since. A subpoena to attend court, for example, is impossible against bitcoin members, because none of them "control" bitcoin. This is one of the main reasons that bitcoin is not able to be shut down by governments, as well as its further decentralization of mining occuring all over the world (although there is concentration of mining in certain parts of the globe, which has become a security concern for the blockchain).
As stated in a previous post, code of any coin with its codebase opensourced can certainly be forked into a new project. Bitcoin Cash, Bitcoin Gold, Bitcoin SV (Satoshi's Vision) are all forks of the original bitcoin, but in terms of network effect, they cannot compete with the original bitcoin (just look at their price). Plus, these coins were forked because some developers did not agree with aspects (technological and philisophical) of the original bitcoin, thus forked and customized the code to what they wanted. The price of these forked coins shows which coin the market believes in (hint: the original bitcoin).
In the genesis block of bitcoin (the first ever minted block), Satoshi Nakamoto inserted a quote from The Times (UK), dated January 3rd, 2009:
"Chancellor on brink of second bailout for banks"
This can give us an idea of the purpose of bitcoin.