Strategy for the 2025 NISA

sutebayashi
Veteran
Posts: 701
Joined: Tue Nov 07, 2017 2:29 pm

Re: Strategy for the 2025 NISA

Post by sutebayashi »

Bubblegun wrote: Tue Oct 22, 2024 6:15 am Sadly it would pay tax if we make a withdrawal.
Drat, the pesky problem of the gains not being all yours when you realize them!
it will be sold at the rate in December and the rebought asap in January.



My thinking is move it to the NISA!

Any reasons NOT to move it?
I agree with your thinking, especially given that you don’t intend to fill your NiSA up with fresh funds next year.

What I might offer though is to not be too eager on doing it in December / January. I would take a wait and see approach. After a possible Santa Claus rally may not be the best time to sell. (If the world is collapsing in the wake of upcoming political events then maybe it would be but that’s not my base case).
(secondarily if you do furusato nozei then selling in the new year is definitely preferable since you’d leave yourself little time at year end to do the furusato nozei donation)

Imagine if the market corrects by 10% some time next year (or currency movement creates a similar effect) and you sell then - you would realize less profit (boohoo), and thus have less tax to pay (hooray), before reinvesting into nisa at a lower price.

When to sell is the difficult part obviously, have to see what is going on in the world. But to avoid time out of the market, you could consider splitting your selling / buying into smaller chunks, so that after you get cash for the first sale you can sell the next tranche and buy back a tranche in nisa at the same time, minimizing the amount of money you have out of the market - assuming you are working with no load mutual funds, and don’t pay transaction costs.

Whether it is worth the bother to try to save on some tax comes down to you :)
If you say sell 2.6 million worth, realize up to 1.3 million in taxable profit, it’d make for circa 260,000 capital gains tax. But if you could sell lower and pay only 200,000 capital gains say, that’d be the difference… 60,000 yen immediately but tax protected thereafter.
Personally I will try to amuse myself in this way, for even less possible tax savings :)
User avatar
adamu
Sensei
Posts: 2322
Joined: Wed Aug 02, 2017 11:43 pm
Location: Fukuoka
Contact:

Re: Strategy for the 2025 NISA

Post by adamu »

Worst case:

You sell in December, occurring 20% CGT bill.
The price goes up before you can rebuy.
You are at a loss, but still have to pay the tax.
adamu wrote: Mon May 08, 2023 12:55 am If you sell early and the market gains between when you sell and the end of the year, you lose out on the tax free gains.

This is why I think selling existing investments is a distraction. It's going to encourage you to do market timing, expose you to risk of being out of the market, and distract from the much simpler, more important, and beneficial habit of regular saving.
goodandbadjapan
Veteran
Posts: 385
Joined: Thu Aug 03, 2017 1:01 pm

Re: Strategy for the 2025 NISA

Post by goodandbadjapan »

Sorry to take this slightly off tangent but it does relate to next year's NISA - does the tsumitate bit you have set up for this year automatically start up again next year or do we need to do something to get it going again?
User avatar
RetireJapan
Site Admin
Posts: 4718
Joined: Wed Aug 02, 2017 6:57 am
Location: Sendai
Contact:

Re: Strategy for the 2025 NISA

Post by RetireJapan »

goodandbadjapan wrote: Wed Oct 23, 2024 1:01 am Sorry to take this slightly off tangent but it does relate to next year's NISA - does the tsumitate bit you have set up for this year automatically start up again next year or do we need to do something to get it going again?
Once you set it up it continues running until you cancel or change it (or there are not enough funds for the payment to go through).
English teacher and writer. RetireJapan founder. Avid reader.

eMaxis Slim Shady 8-)
Tsumitate Wrestler
Veteran
Posts: 626
Joined: Wed Oct 04, 2023 1:06 pm

Re: Strategy for the 2025 NISA

Post by Tsumitate Wrestler »

RetireJapan wrote: Wed Oct 23, 2024 1:04 am
goodandbadjapan wrote: Wed Oct 23, 2024 1:01 am Sorry to take this slightly off tangent but it does relate to next year's NISA - does the tsumitate bit you have set up for this year automatically start up again next year or do we need to do something to get it going again?
Once you set it up it continues running until you cancel or change it (or there are not enough funds for the payment to go through).
Most Security companies will automatically cancel a tsumitate setting after X number of failures, due to insufficient funds.

It is a bit different with each broker.
goodandbadjapan
Veteran
Posts: 385
Joined: Thu Aug 03, 2017 1:01 pm

Re: Strategy for the 2025 NISA

Post by goodandbadjapan »

RetireJapan wrote: Wed Oct 23, 2024 1:04 am
goodandbadjapan wrote: Wed Oct 23, 2024 1:01 am Sorry to take this slightly off tangent but it does relate to next year's NISA - does the tsumitate bit you have set up for this year automatically start up again next year or do we need to do something to get it going again?
Once you set it up it continues running until you cancel or change it (or there are not enough funds for the payment to go through).
Thank you!
Bubblegun
Veteran
Posts: 666
Joined: Sun May 05, 2019 2:45 am

Re: Strategy for the 2025 NISA

Post by Bubblegun »

adamu wrote: Tue Oct 22, 2024 2:15 pm Worst case:

You sell in December, occurring 20% CGT bill.
The price goes up before you can rebuy.
You are at a loss, but still have to pay the tax.
adamu wrote: Mon May 08, 2023 12:55 am If you sell early and the market gains between when you sell and the end of the year, you lose out on the tax free gains.

This is why I think selling existing investments is a distraction. It's going to encourage you to do market timing, expose you to risk of being out of the market, and distract from the much simpler, more important, and beneficial habit of regular saving.
Interesting. I wonder! If only we had that crystal ball! I will have to chat with the the family, and see what they think.

I'm inclined to sell some, and move it to the NISA because we can't move it all anyway. DCA but with larger amounts. Maybe just do it, cause we can't time the market but we can use that time IN THE NISA MARKET It's that ANALYSIS PARALYSIS. Over thinking everthing.
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/an ... alysis.asp
Baldrick. Trying to save the world.
User avatar
adamu
Sensei
Posts: 2322
Joined: Wed Aug 02, 2017 11:43 pm
Location: Fukuoka
Contact:

Re: Strategy for the 2025 NISA

Post by adamu »

There is no NISA market though, there's only tax protected or not tax protected. By selling existing funds, you are temporarily taking them out of the market. That's not a risk-free operation.
beanhead
Sensei
Posts: 1212
Joined: Sat Jan 30, 2021 1:24 pm
Location: Kanto

Re: Strategy for the 2025 NISA

Post by beanhead »

Bubblegun wrote: Wed Oct 23, 2024 2:10 pm
Interesting. I wonder! If only we had that crystal ball! I will have to chat with the the family, and see what they think.

I'm inclined to sell some, and move it to the NISA because we can't move it all anyway. DCA but with larger amounts. Maybe just do it, cause we can't time the market but we can use that time IN THE NISA MARKET It's that ANALYSIS PARALYSIS. Over thinking everthing.
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/an ... alysis.asp
Anyone who has money invested in the Tokutei account and cannot save 3.6M per year has the same kind of thoughts, I think.
As you get closer to 60 or 65 or whatever, there is the desire to fill up the NISA as quickly as possible, which of course means selling taxable assets.

I may trick myself into not worrying about re-purchase prices by buying different assets. So sell S&P500 and buy All-Country or sell All-Country and buy the ex-Japan fund :lol:
Aiming to retire at 60 and live for a while longer. 95% index funds (eMaxis Slim etc), 5% Japanese dividend stocks.
Tsumitate Wrestler
Veteran
Posts: 626
Joined: Wed Oct 04, 2023 1:06 pm

Re: Strategy for the 2025 NISA

Post by Tsumitate Wrestler »

We are selling taxable assets, and moving them in 800,000 yen tranches to the New Nisa Growth, over 1 month, just in case we get caught in a market swing.

After a home purchase, and straddling reforms and current rental accommodations across a 1 year span, we will have less disposable income.

88,000 IDeco +100,000 yen NISA as a couple will be our likely contribution limit for the next decade or so.

Therefore, filling it up with taxable assets makes more sense.

Our Goals will be for our NISAs to be full by 2030. *
---------
*(If the government decides to double iDeco limits, as the chatter suggests, we may change our focus. But due to retirement allowances for my wife, the Min/max data might take some number crunching. Currently I only pay base nenkin, so going fullbore on iDeco is the most logical step at present).
Post Reply