Lessons from the Future
Another real treat for you today: the experiences of someone who went through the system in Japan and then successfully retired. Take it away, Parker!
Early Retirement: Lessons from an Unsophisticated Investor
by Parker Dupont
I retired at 61, just shy of the 62nd birthday required to start my pension. I could have continued working for another 8 years at my university but gave up an excellent salary for the prospect of becoming free from classes, meetings, and deadlines.
In hindsight it was a wonderful decision. I was able to retire early due to both luck and discipline. The following piece explains how I was able to reach this happy situation and is illustrated with actual figures for amounts received/being received to give you a concrete idea of what you may be getting one day.
My secret weapon
I am undoubtedly lucky as I found the right partner. When I met my wife about 35 years ago, she was already determined to have a full-time career and also to save for a comfortable retirement. We consulted with a financial advisor soon after marrying and have since adhered to the basics he recommended. That is, making and sticking to saving goals (we have long set ours at least 20% of each income), and maintaining diversified and balanced portfolios in mostly separate his and her accounts.
With both of us working fulltime and raising a family as dotingly as possible, neither had time to play the role of hands-on investor. We generally avoided buying stocks directly, and invested in mutual funds which we never toyed with.
We spread any saving/investing all over – in offshore instruments (through those deservedly infamous advisors present at JALT conferences), Citibank Japan (before they were kicked out), Nomura, real estate, and even in the日本私立学校振興・共済事業団 or the Private School Mutual Aid Corporation (hereafter PMAC) savings plan, giving us a mixture of savings/investment in yen, Australian and US dollars.
Ultimately, we saved a lot but there was disappointingly little capital gain except in foreign real estate which continues to appreciate as well as provide income. Although there were periods when money was really tight because one of us was between full-time jobs or because we were paying for our children’s education, we still continued to put aside money each month, as each of us had done since the 1980s. We set a highly ambitious savings target but ended up handily clearing it.
Lessons from my experience
I wholeheartedly recommend the standard advice to always save a certain percentage of your income, no matter how modest your total pay might be, and from your very first payday. Try to make that percentage at least 20%. Spread the risk by diversifying into index funds and real estate, both domestic & foreign. That way, you’ll never have worry too much about currency changes.
The bulk of my saving was achieved through automatic deductions from my salary and credit card (a pleasant result of the latter being the accumulation of many FF miles which I will use to fly business class). Using the same method, my wife and I have long supported our favorite local & international charities as monthly supporters.
Saving certainly became easier for us as we grew more deliberate about our expenditure. For the past 25 years we were always able to afford the latest Apple gizmo/Italian suit/German coupe but very rarely were we tempted.
Saving, rather than spending, became fun. Just as importantly, we both agreed that we needed to enjoy any money left-over after saving, figuring that we deserved to reward ourselves for saving success. The family vacations that resulted will be hard to forget.
Doubling your household income helps greatly. Even math-allergic language teachers recognize that two salaries must be better than one if you are married/partnered. If possible, also be a little ambitious and climb the career ladder. Saving 20% of the tenured 10million+ yen annual salary I was on got me retired far quicker than saving 20% of the 3-4million yen eikaiwa gig I started out on. I am always surprised to learn that even now highly-paid tenured jobs attract few qualified applicants.
Just as it is for a good portfolio, a good CV does not come into fruition overnight. Work on your employment credentials as steadily as you save, and both will build up over time.
You need to be ready for the unplanned. Things change – and enormously. On my first trip to Japan in 1980 one US dollar got you ¥220 and one Aussie dollar which currently trades for ¥90 was worth even more at¥290. Australian bank account holders in 1987 with more than $20,000 deposited got a return of 11.75% interest. The small Sydney apartment (one room manshon-style) we bought for investment in 1985 received just $300 a month in rent at first but that has now increased to over $1,000. That same manshon has appreciated 7-8 times its original cost – a far better outcome than if we had mistakenly bought into Japan’s mid-bubble property market of the time.
Additionally, we had no idea that one of our kids was going to get a Masters in the US. That was super expensive to pay for but because of our double incomes and built-up savings, we did it without incurring any debt and I still retired 5 years earlier than the 67 I had loosely aimed for many years earlier. Whatever the amount you think you need to support your retired life may not be enough so having an extra 20-30% cushion is good for covering the unforeseen. But how much is enough?
Japanese Pensions
PMAC which pays my pension here estimates that a couple requires a monthly minimum of ¥220,000 to support a very basic retirement, and further suggests¥354,000 is needed for them to enjoy a slightly affluent lifestyle (assuming home ownership and no mortgage remaining).
Unfortunately, depending on your age you also should assume that future Japanese nenkin, both kokumin and employer-based, will provide 10%-30% less than they do at the moment, and also that future generations are not likely to get a pension until age 70.
After 18 years of paying into PMAC, I now get a partial pension of ¥84,000 a month. People born after 1961, however, cannot get their PMAC pension until they turn 65. Currently.
From 65, I will also receive kokumin nenkin but only around ¥43,000 a month since I have only paid in for 27 years. So together they total ¥127,000 monthly, which would necessitate a large monthly drain on my savings if I did not have other non-Japanese income sources to supplement my income (PMAC members, are you aware that you can get an estimate of your future pension over the phone from your local office? You just need to provide your membership information and give them a couple of minutes to crunch numbers).
Given the demographic future of Japan, its relatively poor public and private pension systems, and the unfortunate likelihood of future natural disasters, those young enough to be still uncommitted might want to seriously rethink their future in this country. I love Japan and have greatly enjoyed living here but there are few advanced countries with as bleak a future for the aged.
This is not just my subjective opinion. The recently released 2017 NATIXIS Global Retirement Index rated Japan at #22 of the 43 countries surveyed. The UK came in at #18, the USA at #17, leaving only Australia 6th and New Zealand 5th to battle with the usual suspects from Europe for a top 10 placing. For details see this report.
Those without the choice of moving to Norway or some similarly promising pasture should think long and hard about how you are going to generate sufficient monthly income to support your retirement. Unlike the good old 1980s when even Japanese banks offered 8% interest rates, having 100 million yen saved in a Japanese bank now is not going generate much for you, if anything at all.
There is, however, some good news about jobs
in Japan and that is the forced savings built into the system. ‘Proper’ jobs come with 2-3 bonuses a year and those lump sums can really boost saving efforts.
Additionally, the retirement bonus system in place here gives workers a huge chunk of cash right at the end when it really helps. I received a lump sum totaling over 1 million yen for each year that I worked, but readers should note that payment amounts vary greatly according to your employment conditions, salary level, type/size of school, your age at retirement, and length of service.
Retiring after age 50 with more than 15 years of employment at my university meant I got a far greater total payout than a younger professor would have received for the same length of time.
For university teachers, I am told that staying within one pension system for a long period, either the private or public university system, is apparently much more financially advantageous than splitting your career between two. Finally, unlike for many retirees living in America, because we plan to continue to be based in Japan, we do not worry about how to cover our future medical costs. And that is a big, big deal.
Final words
In hindsight our efforts to save can be viewed as a form of delayed gratification. We worked and saved hard over a long term in order to put ourselves into a position of having more options later in life, only later has become now.
Retirement for me so far has meant an instantly happier and healthier life without any decline in living standards. I am thrilled to be retired and look forward to spreading my wings to travel more and also to find ways to give back to my local community.
Life could hardly be better. I hope readers can get themselves into a similar situation one day too. In our case all it required was adhering to very basic investment principles, a ton of luck along the way and decades of effort.
And on that cheerful note, I retire. Literally.
Thank you so much for taking the time to write that, Parker. I’m sure it will be of interest to anyone planning to stay in Japan until retirement.
I’m not quite as gloomy as Parker about Japan’s future prospects (I think automation is going to transform the economy again) but I completely agree that the safest thing is to make sure you can take care of yourself. Expecting the government to do so seems risky to say the least!
How about you? Would you like to share your experiences in a Reader Profile? How is your retirement going/looking?
Very interesting. I am in my early 50s now and no luck finding work after a year searching. 3 decades here and due to contract work and breaks that mean my pension will not be there, I have to look at my savings at these past 6 months have been sobering. For the next 30 years with no investments I apparently can budget Y500,000 a month as I am single and no kids. Health insurance is covered due to 4 citizenship I have which I know would be the biggest burden but with very low chances of finding work in Japan due to agism, I will leave by December and see what the rest of the world can offer. I hope Y500,000 will hold me as I study economics of how to deal with my savings and make smart decisions. I don’t want to retire yet but Japan is not the place of milk and honey anymore. I don’t even make enough to cover my rent here these past 16 months and so time to leave. Thanks for the numbers as that gives me confidence to move forward.
I hope you find a good solution! Good luck.
Please post questions in the forum if you need help or information: https://www.retirejapan.com/forum/
Mattej, Perhaps I am being naive but I was under the impression that Japanese EFL students preffered middle aged EFL teachers with experience of life. I am 59 and when in Japan earlier this year I was asked to consider teaching EFL at a Juku should I return to Japan on a permanent basis.
Maybe I’ve misunderstood something but are you saying you have enough to survive on ¥500,000 a month for 30 years? If so, I don’t think you have a lot to worry about.
I don’t think one ever feels financially secure. Japan has changed so much and as a N1 Level biochemist, I can’t understand why there is so much ageism in Japan. Over 45, companies don’t want to touch you despite being in niche markets and being complete with PR and presentable for many companies. I think many here that have been here 30 years remember the great years of endless offers but now after endless searching and interviews, I would love to use what I have learned over all these years. My feeling is I am out of here this year as the offers or follow-up by companies is simply not there.
Thanks Parker, it was a great read. Just like Ben, I’m a bit more optimistic than you are about the future of Japan for our seniors. If anything, Japan has lots of them so will have to learn how to deal with them. As a matter of fact, I feel that the laws/politics here are heavily biased in favor of seniors. Conversely, young people and families with kids have a harder time than in other countries, in my humble opinion.
Ah, yeah…, retiring early.
One thing I wrestled with about 5-6 years ago was whether to take the money and run, and gamble on the f/x rate and then the market, or whether to stay on till my “normal” retirement (the next March 31st following my 65th birthday).
At the time the yen/$ rate had gone below 80/$, and that seemed really attractive. But the retirement scheme at my school (based on a chart in the rule book) was like this: If I quit on my own—voluntary retirement ( = resigning on my own)—I would have gotten about 27 times my base salary; if I stayed until I was 65—regular retirement (定年退職)—I would get 47.5 times my base salary. The latter is what I opted for, but here’s what I was thinking.
In dollar terms, how would (a) 27 x base salary @ 80/$ compare to (b) 47.5 X base salary at some future (and unknown) rate? If the exchange rate stayed at 90 or so, or went to 105/$, or 115/$, or 125/$, what would the difference between those two figures be? Add in the further question of what the market would do in the meantime—if I had taken that lump sum back then, converted it to $ and invested it, in retrospect that would have worked out pretty well. But there would have been some risk in that bet on the market at the time.
Include the bird-in-hand factor: Work was easy & enjoyable, and I was easily saving half my income (and income would have plummeted had I quit).
So, I stayed, and instead of quitting (“retiring”) early, I opted for the added income & savings, along with the larger severance payout by retiring at the prescribed time. And, there was what I’ll call the “I vs. we” factor—I was considering retirement, but my wife (also a full prof, different school), being about 5-6 yrs younger than me, was not thinking at all about retirement. (She may bail at 62, but may also go to 65.)
This supposed “Parker Dupont” offers that…
[quote] I retired at 61, …. I could have continued working for another 8 years at my university…[/quote]
…but he doesn’t say if he was a regular faculty member (正社員), in which case there would probably have been a regular retirement date (65, after which he might have become 特任教授), or if he was contracted.
If he was regular faculty, it might have been to his advantage to work till 65; if contracted, it likely would not make a difference.
I could have worked until 70, after which I may or may not have been invited to continue on a contract. Also, there is no penalty for retiring earlier than the mandated age at my university. Good to see that you are socking away savings Captainspoke. Keep it up!
My university also differentiates between finishing (reaching retirement age, currently 62 or the end of a contract) and quitting with regards to retirement bonuses (退職金).
Can make quite a big difference! I am planning to stay until the end of my next contract in 4.5 years time 🙂
Also, retire japan.org, why don’t you say out front and at the beginning that “Parker Dupont” is an alias to protect the innocent?
Hi CS
I always run comments and reader profiles with whatever name people choose to give. Privacy is important to some people when talking about money 🙂
“Parker Dupont” is not a real person. It is unfortunate that retirejapan.org did not offer this up in the beginning.
The use of ‘Parker Dupont’ is a rather obvious pen name used for a bit of humor. If I need to explain it, then it wouldn’t be funny. Hardly affects the content does it?
[quote]I am thrilled to be retired and look forward to … find ways to give back to my local community.
[/quote]
This is what I’d like the hear about. What are your ideas?
I am still looking for opportunities to contribute.I will be soon be doing training to help organize native English speakers during emergencies. Currently looking into UNCHR possibilities as a fundraiser. I am mostly looking out for Japanese NGOs which could use my limited skills and that I think do inspiring work. I have talked to several but either they require too little commitment (one charity event a year) or they want me to teach English. I didn’t retire just to start doing more of the same, even if it is for a good cause. Selfish as it may appear, I want to be inspired by something new.
How does one go about investing in foreign real estate? Seems like a lot of difficulty to set up and manage, both here and abroad.